Risk Management Strategies

A Chimney Collapses at Asansol, a Fab Site Stops Work in Kaohsiung: What CAR, EC and Delay-in-Start-Up Pay When a Fatality Halts a Project

A chimney collapse at Shyam SEL and Power in Asansol and four deaths at TSMC's Fab 22 site show how a fatality halts a project. Here is what CAR, delay-in-start-up and EC cover will and will not pay.

Tarun Kumar Singh
Tarun Kumar SinghStrategic Risk & Compliance SpecialistAIII · CRICP · CIAFP
8 min read

Listen to this article

Audio version • 8 min read

contractors all riskdelay in start-upemployees compensationstop-work orderprincipal employerconstruction safety

Last reviewed: November 2026

Two Fatal Site Events in One Week

On the evening of 17 October 2026, part of a chimney under construction collapsed at Shyam SEL And Power Limited in Jamuria, Asansol, West Bengal. HSEBlog, citing NDTV and IANS, reported that four workers were killed and one was seriously injured. The local MLA, Bijan Mukherjee, said an inquiry would examine what happened. The cause has not been established.

Three days later, on 20 October 2026, four construction workers employed by a domestic contractor died during steel-structure work at TSMC's Fab 22 construction site in Nanzi District, Kaohsiung. HSEBlog, citing Reuters and Focus Taiwan, reported that police suspect the workers fell with a steel beam during welding. TSMC halted some construction work, and the Southern Taiwan Science Park Bureau ordered steel-beam lifting stopped and the scene preserved.

The two events are different in scale and jurisdiction, and neither cause is known. This post does not speculate on either. What they share is the sequence every project owner should plan for: a fatal accident, an inquiry, a partial or full halt ordered by the owner or an authority, and then a set of questions about who pays for the damaged works, the lost time and the workers' families.

Those questions apply directly to Indian builds: captive power plants and chimneys at steel and sponge iron units, process plant expansions, and the semiconductor and ATMP projects at Dholera and Sanand, where steel erection and heavy lifts are on the critical path.

How the CAR or EAR Policy Treats the Collapsed Works

A contractors' all risks (CAR) or erection all risks (EAR) policy covers sudden and unforeseen physical loss or damage to the contract works during the period of construction. A partial chimney collapse or a dropped structural member is, on its face, physical damage to the insured works. The material damage section is where the first claim sits.

Three policy features decide how much of that claim is paid:

  1. Cause and the design/workmanship exclusions. Most CAR wordings exclude, or limit cover for, the cost of rectifying defective design, material or workmanship, often through LEG-style clauses that pay for consequential damage to other parts of the works but not for the defective part itself. Until the inquiry establishes a cause, nobody can say which clause applies, which is why the surveyor's early findings matter.
  2. Debris removal. Clearing a collapsed chimney section or a fallen steel frame is expensive and is usually covered only up to a separately stated sum insured or a percentage of the claim. Owners should check that this limit reflects realistic demolition and clearance cost for tall structures, not a nominal figure.
  3. Extra costs. Express freight, overtime and escalation to recover the programme are typically extensions with their own limits. Without them, the material damage claim covers rebuilding at normal cost only.

The deductible also matters. Many CAR policies carry a higher deductible for major perils or for testing and commissioning, and the rebuild of a tall structure can be split into multiple events if the policy wording allows it.

Why Delay in Start-Up Rarely Pays for a Stop-Work Order

Delay in start-up (DSU), also called advance loss of profits or ALOP, pays the owner's lost gross profit or debt service when the project's scheduled commercial operation date slips. The trigger is almost always the same as the material damage section: the delay must result from insured physical loss or damage to the works. Our longer note on DSU and ALOP for industrial projects covers the mechanics.

That trigger is the problem with regulatory halts. A stop-work order issued after a fatality can stop every crane on site, including work on parts of the project that are entirely undamaged. In the Kaohsiung case, the bureau's order was framed around an activity, steel-beam lifting work, rather than around a damaged part of the works. For DSU purposes, that is a loss of time without insured damage behind it.

Insurers usually separate the delay into parts:

  • Delay caused by the damage itself (rebuilding the collapsed section) is in principle covered once the waiting period is exceeded.
  • Delay caused by an authority's order, an inquiry, or the preservation of the scene may be argued to fall outside cover, either because many wordings exclude delay from orders of public authority or because the delay is not caused by damage to insured property.
  • Delay caused by labour withdrawal, protests or the contractor's own remobilisation after a fatality is generally not caused by insured damage and is not covered.

In practice, the adjuster will build a critical-path analysis and attribute days to each cause. Owners who keep a clean, dated programme and a record of each instruction from authorities are better placed in that exercise.

Employees' Compensation When the Workers Belong to a Subcontractor

At Fab 22 the workers who died were employed by a domestic contractor, not by TSMC. Reports on Asansol have not said who employed the workers there, but on Indian sites contractor labour is the norm: chimney erection, structural steel and heavy lifting are usually done by specialist subcontractors.

Indian law does not let the owner or main contractor walk away from that fact. Section 12 of the Employee's Compensation Act, 1923 made a principal who engages a contractor to carry out work that is part of the principal's trade or business liable to pay compensation to the contractor's workers as if they were the principal's own employees, with a right of indemnity against the contractor. The Act was replaced when the labour codes came into force on 21 November 2025, and these provisions are carried forward in the employee compensation chapter of the Code on Social Security, 2020, while site safety duties for building and construction work sit in the Occupational Safety, Health and Working Conditions Code, 2020.

The practical consequence is that a dependant can claim against whoever is solvent and reachable, and the owner's recovery depends on the contractor having insured its own liability. Our note on employers' liability for contract labour sets out the chain in more detail.

The common gaps on construction sites are:

  • the subcontractor's EC policy has lapsed, is under-declared on wages or headcount, or does not name the site;
  • the main contractor's EC policy covers its own payroll but not workers of sub-subcontractors;
  • the owner relies on a CAR third-party section, which usually excludes bodily injury to workers employed on the contract.

Statutory compensation is only part of the exposure after a fatal accident. Ex gratia payments announced at the site, medical expenses for the injured, and any civil claim or criminal proceeding sit outside a basic EC policy unless common law liability and medical extensions have been bought.

Contract Clauses That Decide Who Pays

Insurance follows the contract. After a fatal collapse, these clauses settle most of the arguments:

  1. Insurance obligation. Whether the owner arranges a project-wide CAR/EAR policy covering all contractors as joint insureds, or each contractor insures its own scope. Owner-controlled programmes avoid gaps between packages but put the owner's claims record at stake.
  2. Indemnity for personnel. Most EPC and erection contracts make each party responsible for injury to its own people, regardless of fault. The owner's indemnity is only as good as the contractor's balance sheet and EC policy.
  3. Evidence of cover. A right to receive and verify a certificate of insurance and the schedule of wage declarations before mobilisation, and to stop payment if cover lapses.
  4. Suspension and force majeure. Whether a stop-work order by an authority after an accident is an excusable event that extends time, and who bears the standby costs. If the order stems from the contractor's safety breach, many contracts treat it as contractor risk.
  5. Liquidated damages. If DSU does not respond to regulatory delay, delay LDs from the contractor may be the owner's only recovery, subject to the contract cap.
  6. Waiver of subrogation. Whether the CAR insurer can recover from a negligent subcontractor, or whether all project parties are protected.

The handover stage creates its own gaps, which we cover in the construction-to-operational handover note.

What Semiconductor and Captive Power Owners Should Check Now

The Fab 22 halt is a reminder that semiconductor builds carry very high daily delay values and extensive steel erection. Indian owners at Dholera and Sanand, and those building captive power and heavy industrial plants, can test their programmes against a simple list:

  • Is DSU sum insured and indemnity period set on a realistic delay scenario, including time to clear debris and re-procure long-lead items?
  • Does the DSU wording exclude delay from orders of public authority, and has the broker asked whether a limited extension is available?
  • Are debris removal and extra cost limits sized for tall structures and heavy steel, not set at a default figure?
  • Does every subcontractor on site, down to the labour supplier, have a live EC policy with correct wage declarations and the site address?
  • Has the principal employer bought its own EC or employers' liability cover with a principal's liability extension, so it is not relying solely on contractors?
  • Does the CAR third-party section, or a separate public liability policy, respond to injury to people outside the works, such as visitors and neighbours?

Lender requirements often fix the DSU structure. Where the financing model assumes no regulatory delay, owners should raise that gap with lenders early rather than after an event.

The First 72 Hours After a Fatal Site Accident

The claims position is set in the first few days. A disciplined sequence helps:

  1. Notify all relevant insurers: CAR/EAR, DSU, EC (owner's and contractors'), and liability. Late notice is a common ground for dispute.
  2. Preserve evidence and record any authority's order, including its scope and date. Photograph the scene before and after any permitted clearance.
  3. Collect contractor insurance documents for every worker involved: employer name, EC policy number, declared wages.
  4. Start a delay log separating time lost to damage, to the authority's order, and to labour or remobilisation issues.
  5. Coordinate public statements and ex gratia payments with insurers and legal advisers, so that announced payments do not prejudice cover or liability positions.

None of this requires knowing the cause, and it should not wait for the inquiry. The inquiry's findings will matter later, both for the CAR exclusions and for any recovery against a responsible party.

About the Author

Tarun Kumar Singh

Tarun Kumar Singh

Strategic Risk & Compliance Specialist

  • AIII
  • CRICP
  • CIAFP
  • Board Advisor, Finexure Consulting
  • Developer of the Behavioural Underinsurance Risk Index (BURI)

Tarun Kumar Singh is a seasoned risk management and insurance professional based in Bengaluru. He serves as Board Advisor at Finexure Consulting, where he advises insurance, fintech, and regulated firms on governance, growth, and trust. His work spans insurance broker regulatory frameworks across India, UAE, and ASEAN, IRDAI compliance and Corporate Agency model reform, VC governance in insurtech, and MSME insurance gap analysis. He is the developer of the Behavioural Underinsurance Risk Index (BURI), a framework applying behavioural economics to underinsurance and insurance fraud risk.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does a CAR policy pay for debris removal after a structure collapses during construction?
Usually yes, but only up to a separately stated debris removal limit or a percentage of the claim. For tall structures such as chimneys or heavy steel frames, the default limit is often too low, so owners should check it against realistic clearance costs.
Will delay-in-start-up cover pay if an authority orders work stopped after a fatal accident?
Generally not for the part of the delay caused by the order itself. DSU is triggered by insured physical damage to the works. Delay attributable to rebuilding damaged works may be covered, but delay from an authority's order on undamaged parts, from an inquiry or from labour withdrawal is usually outside cover.
Is the project owner liable if a subcontractor's worker dies on site?
It can be. Indian employee compensation law makes a principal who engages a contractor for work forming part of its business liable to pay compensation to the contractor's workers, with a right of indemnity against the contractor. The owner should verify each contractor's EC policy and consider its own principal's liability cover.
Does the CAR third-party section cover injury to workers on the site?
Usually not. Most CAR third-party sections exclude bodily injury to employees or workers of the insured parties engaged on the contract. That exposure belongs under employees' compensation or employers' liability policies.
What should an owner do first after a fatal accident on a project?
Notify all insurers promptly, preserve the scene and any authority's order, collect each contractor's insurance documents, and start a delay log that separates time lost to damage from time lost to the authority's order or labour issues.

Related Glossary Terms

Related Insurance Types

Related Industries

Related Articles

Sarvada Intelligence

Ready to see Sarvada in action?

Explore the platform workflow or start a product conversation with our underwriting automation team.

Explore the platform