What the Supreme Court Has Been Asked to Do
A Supreme Court bench of CJI Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana has sought responses from the Centre and others on a public interest litigation filed by the National Campaign Committee for Central Legislation on Construction Labour, as reported by Asia Insurance Post on 21 September 2026. The PIL asks for three things that matter to anyone who insures, builds or finances construction in India:
- Occupational safety and health standards for building and other construction work under the Occupational Safety, Health and Working Conditions Code, 2020 (the OSH Code).
- A uniform national mechanism to record, compile and periodically publish construction fatalities, serious injuries, causes, inspections, prosecutions, and compensation and welfare benefits paid.
- An independent, time-bound investigation into the 9 March 2026 collapse at a construction site in Gurugram's Sidhrawali area (Signature Global City of Colours), including scrutiny of the developer, its directors, management, safety officials and engineers, with compensation for the workers who died or were injured.
Arguing the plea, counsel Prashant Bhushan told the Court that the OSH Code does not adequately address construction safety, that an FIR is usually the only step taken after a site mishap, and that there is no mechanism to ascertain compensation paid to workers.
Notice is not a judgment. The Centre may contest the plea, and any standards or reporting mechanism will take time. But the direction of travel is clear, and developers and contractors who wait for the final order will be reviewing their insurance after the rules have changed.
Why Public Fatality Data Would Change Underwriting
Construction is underwritten in India with thin data. Insurers pricing employees' compensation (EC) and contractors' all risks (CAR) policies rely on wage declarations, project values, a site visit for larger risks and their own claims experience. There is no public, project-level record of fatalities and serious injuries to test a developer's or contractor's safety record against.
A national reporting mechanism of the kind the PIL seeks would change that in three ways:
- Account-level pricing. Underwriters could check a contractor's history across projects rather than relying on the proposal form. Contractors with repeated incidents would face higher rates or restricted terms; those with clean records would have evidence to negotiate with.
- Disclosure exposure. Once fatalities are published, an incident that was not disclosed at renewal becomes easy to find. That raises utmost good faith and non-disclosure risk for insureds who under-report.
- Compensation benchmarks. Publishing the compensation actually paid would show the gap between statutory compensation, ex gratia payments, court awards and what the EC policy funded.
Set safety standards under the OSH Code would add a second effect: a clear benchmark for whether a site was compliant. That cuts both ways. A compliant site has a defence. A non-compliant site gives the insurer, the regulator and any claimant a ready-made breach to point to.
Employees' Compensation: Limits, Wages and the Gap
The EC policy is the first line of cover for injury to a contractor's own workers. It indemnifies the employer for statutory compensation and, if extended, for common law liability and medical expenses. Three problems recur on construction sites.
Wage declarations that do not match the site
EC premiums are based on declared wages and headcount. Construction labour turns over constantly, and declarations made at inception are often far below the actual wage roll by mid-project. Where the wage roll is understated, insurers may apply average or dispute cover for workers who were never declared. Monthly declaration or a declaration-and-adjustment basis fits site reality better than a fixed annual estimate.
Statutory compensation versus actual outcomes
Statutory compensation is formula-driven. Developers facing a fatal collapse frequently pay ex gratia sums well above the statutory figure, under public or political pressure. The EC policy pays the statutory liability (and any extensions bought), not the ex gratia payment. If the PIL leads to published compensation data, that gap will be visible, and it will be the developer or contractor who funds it.
Contract labour. Most site workers are employed through sub-contractors. Under labour law the principal employer can be liable if the immediate employer fails to pay. Our post on employers' liability and contract labour covers principal-employer exposure. In practice, check that every sub-contractor holds its own EC policy, that the policies are current, and that your own policy covers the principal's liability for sub-contractors' workers, or that the sub-contractors' policies name you.
CAR Third-Party Cover and Worker Injury
The CAR policy has two parts: material damage to the works and, in Section II, third-party liability. After a collapse, both are engaged, but neither is designed to compensate the workers on site.
- Material damage. A structural collapse during construction is a classic contractors' all risks loss. Watch the exclusions for faulty design and defective workmanship, which can limit recovery for the failed element even when consequential damage to other parts of the works is covered.
- Third-party liability. Section II covers injury to third parties and damage to their property. It typically excludes injury to employees of the contractor or principal, on the basis that those are EC exposures. Workers employed by sub-contractors can fall into a grey zone depending on how "employee" and "insured" are defined.
- Neighbours and the public. A collapse that damages adjoining buildings or injures passers-by is the core Section II exposure. Check that the limit reflects the density around urban sites like those in Gurugram.
For the wider set of developer exposures across project phases, see our real estate developer insurance risk profile.
Does D&O Respond to an Inquiry Over a Site Death?
The PIL specifically asks for scrutiny of the developer's directors and management. That is a D&O question. Will a directors' and officers' liability policy fund the defence of a director investigated over a fatal collapse?
The honest answer is: partly, and only if the wording was bought with this in mind.
- Bodily injury exclusion. Most D&O policies exclude claims for bodily injury and death, because those are meant to sit under liability and EC policies. Many wordings carve back defence costs for directors facing criminal or regulatory proceedings, including those arising from workplace deaths. Check whether yours does.
- Investigation costs. Cover for costs of attending an official investigation or inquiry varies. Some policies cover only formal investigations by named regulators; others cover any body with power to investigate. A court-ordered independent investigation of the kind sought in the PIL may or may not fit the definition.
- Fines and penalties. Penalties under labour law are generally uninsurable as a matter of public policy. Defence costs are a different matter.
- Criminal proceedings. Directors may face criminal charges under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023. Our post on BNS and corporate liability insurance sets out how D&O defence cover interacts with criminal proceedings.
Developers should also check the D&O limit structure. A single investigation into a fatal collapse, involving several directors and senior managers, can consume a modest limit in defence costs alone.
A Pre-Emptive Programme Review for Developers and Contractors
There is no need to wait for the Supreme Court's final order. A review now, in line with the OSH Code obligations already covered in our post on OSH Code 2020 employer liability, puts you ahead of any standards or reporting mechanism that follows.
- Map who employs whom on each site. Developer, principal contractor, sub-contractors, labour contractors. Match each to an EC policy.
- Fix the EC basis. Move to monthly or quarterly wage declarations for active sites, and check the policy covers principal-employer liability.
- Close the CAR gap. Read the Section II employee exclusion against how your sub-contractors' workers are engaged, and confirm limits for urban third-party exposure.
- Read the D&O wording. Bodily injury carve-back for defence costs, definition of investigation, limit adequacy for multiple individuals.
- Align safety records with insurance. Keep incident registers, safety audits and training records in a form you would be willing to see published.
- Disclose accurately at renewal. If a national reporting mechanism appears, anything left off a proposal form will be easy to check.
Documents to Keep Ready if an Inquiry Follows a Collapse
If a site collapse leads to an investigation, the insurers on EC, CAR and D&O, the police and any court-appointed inquiry will all ask for overlapping records. Keep them in one place, by project:
- Approved structural drawings, design calculations and any changes during construction, with sign-offs.
- Safety plans, method statements for high-risk activities and permits issued on the day.
- Site safety officer appointments, qualifications and inspection logs.
- Worker registers, sub-contractor agreements and each sub-contractor's EC policy certificate.
- Training and toolbox talk records.
- Material test certificates and quality inspection reports.
- Incident and near-miss registers.
- Board and committee minutes showing how safety was reported to directors.
The last item matters most for D&O. If directors are scrutinised, the question will be what they knew and what they did. Minutes showing that site safety was reported, questioned and acted on are the best defence a director can have, and they are also what a D&O insurer will want to see before agreeing to fund that defence.
