Global & Cross-Border Insurance

Indian Seafarers on Attacked Ships Twice in Two Weeks: What Manning Agents, Ship Managers and Indian Shipowners Owe Crew, and What Insures It

An Indian wiper died when the India-bound MV Cape Dao was hit off Oman, and 23 Indian crew escaped a burning shadow-fleet tanker off Sochi two weeks later. Here is who owes crew compensation after war-zone casualties, and which policy actually pays.

Sarvada Editorial TeamInsurance Intelligence
10 min read

Listen to this article

Audio version • 10 min read

seafarersp&i insurancemanning agentswar zone compensationshadow fleet

Last reviewed: October 2026

Two Ships, Two Weeks, Two Different Insurance Problems

On 23 September 2026 The Week reported that the MV Cape Dao (IMO 9219020), sailing from Mina Saqr in the UAE to India, had been hit off Oman. Suraj Yadav, a wiper from Deoria in Uttar Pradesh, died of head injuries. The Indian Embassy in Oman said 19 of the 28 crew were Indian; the Forward Seamen's Union of India put the number at 20. The Royal Navy of Oman evacuated the rest.

About two weeks later, on the evening of 6 October, a suspected sea-drone attack set the Liberia-flagged tanker Aframax Rio ablaze off Sochi in the Black Sea. Russia's transport ministry said crude oil was burning openly at sea and that all 23 crew, every one of them an Indian citizen, had been rescued, according to Gulf News. Firefighters could not tackle the blaze because of its intensity, and Sochi restricted access to its coast and beaches. The Kyiv Independent reported that the tanker had been placed on Ukraine's sanctions list as part of Russia's shadow fleet on 12 February 2026.

These are two very different insurance cases with the same victims. Cape Dao is, on what has been reported, a conventional India-bound trade in which a strike on the vessel killed a crew member. The questions there are about which policy answers the death claim and at what scale. Aframax Rio is a vessel whose insurance may not exist in any useful form. The questions there are about who is left holding the liability when the shipowner's cover is absent or void.

This post walks the compensation chain for both. It is a companion to our earlier piece on Indian crew taken in the August 2026 hijackings, which dealt with captivity. Here the subject is death and injury from war perils.

The Legal Chain: MLC, the RPSL Rules and the Employment Agreement

An Indian seafarer's entitlements after a death or injury at sea run through three layers, and each produces a different defendant.

  1. The seafarer employment agreement (SEA) and any collective bargaining agreement (CBA) attached to it. This sets the contractual death and disability compensation, sick wages and repatriation terms. The employer named in it, usually the shipowner or a ship manager acting for the owner, is liable first.
  2. The Maritime Labour Convention, 2006, which India ratified in 2015. Regulation 4.2 makes shipowners liable for sickness, injury and death connected with employment, and the 2014 amendments require financial security for contractual death and long-term disability compensation, alongside Regulation 2.5 security for repatriation and abandonment. Certificates of that security must be carried on board.
  3. The Merchant Shipping (Recruitment and Placement of Seafarers) Rules, 2016, administered by the Directorate General of Shipping. These license Indian manning agents (RPSL holders), require them to place crew only under compliant agreements, and require them to verify that the principal can meet its obligations to the seafarer.

For seafarers on Indian-registered ships, the Employees' Compensation Act, 1923 also applies, which gives the family a statutory floor in addition to the contract.

The practical point for a grieving family is reach. A foreign owner of a single-ship company may be hard to sue and quick to disappear. The Indian manning agent has an office, a licence and a reputation in India. When the owner's insurance pays promptly, the agent is a conduit. When it does not, the agent becomes the most reachable defendant, and DG Shipping can act against its licence.

War-Zone Uplifts: Why the Same Death Costs More in Some Waters

Many Indian seafarers sail under agreements in the International Bargaining Forum (IBF) framework, to which the Indian ITF affiliates, the National Union of Seafarers of India and the Maritime Union of India, are parties. Other crew sail under agreements negotiated by unions such as the Forward Seamen's Union of India, or under company terms that borrow the same structure.

These agreements designate Warlike Operations Areas and High Risk Areas. Inside a designated area, crew typically earn a bonus linked to basic wage, hold the right to refuse to sail with repatriation at company cost, and carry death and disability compensation at a multiple of the ordinary scale. The exact designations, multiples and bonus rates change through the year and differ between agreements, so the operative figures are those in the CBA the seafarer actually signed.

Two consequences follow for the death of a crew member like the Cape Dao wiper.

  • The quantum depends on the paperwork. Whether the vessel was inside a designated area when it was hit, and which agreement governed the wiper's contract, decides whether the family is owed the ordinary scale or the uplifted one.
  • The uplift has to be insured to be paid by an insurer. P&I clubs cover contractual crew liabilities as declared and accepted at entry. An owner who never declared its CBA, or the area uplifts within it, can find the difference between the standard and enhanced compensation sitting on its own account.

A manning agent that places crew under an ITF-linked CBA but cannot show that the principal declared that CBA to its P&I insurer is accepting the risk that the uplift goes unpaid. The agent should ask for the insurer's written confirmation, not the owner's assurance.

P&I Crew Cover Versus War Risks: Where the Death Claim Actually Lands

A shipowner's ordinary liabilities to crew sit in the P&I entry: medical cost, death and disability compensation under the SEA or CBA, repatriation, and substitute crew. But standard club rules exclude liabilities caused by war perils, which include missiles, mines, drones and other weapons of war. A crew death from a strike on the vessel falls into that exclusion.

The excluded war liabilities are usually picked up in two layers:

  1. War P&I under the hull war policy, typically limited to the hull war sum insured.
  2. The club's excess war P&I cover, which sits above that layer for owners entered with the International Group clubs, subject to the club's own cancellation and sanctions provisions.

For a crew claim, this means the first question after a Cape Dao-type incident is not whether the club pays but whether the war layer was in place and in force on the day. War cover for listed areas typically requires notice and an additional premium before entry. A vessel that entered a listed area without the required notice, or whose war cover had been cancelled at short notice, may have a crew death claim that no underwriter accepts.

The MLC certificates complicate this further. The financial security for contractual death and disability compensation must be available to the seafarer, and the International Group clubs that issue most of these certificates have generally structured them so that a valid crew claim against the certificate is not defeated by the war exclusion in the underlying rules. The club pays and seeks recovery from the owner. That protects the seafarer's family on the certificated amount, but it leaves the owner exposed to a recovery action and does nothing for uplifts above the certificated scale.

The Shadow-Fleet Problem: When the Owner's Cover Is Absent or Void

Aframax Rio is where the chain breaks. A tanker placed on a sanctions list as part of a shadow fleet often does not hold an International Group entry at all. Where it does hold cover, it is commonly with insurers whose capacity, claims record and willingness to pay are hard to verify from India. And where a mainstream insurer did write it, sanctions clauses in club rules and in most marine policies allow cover to be suspended or treated as void where paying a claim would expose the insurer to sanctions.

All 23 Indian crew of Aframax Rio were rescued, so the immediate claims here are injury, medical, repatriation, lost wages and personal effects rather than death. The structure of the problem is the same either way.

  • The MLC certificate may be worthless. A certificate issued by an insurer with no assets reachable from India, or one that has walked away from the vessel, gives the family a document and no payer.
  • The owner is a single-ship company. Shadow-fleet tonnage is commonly held through companies whose beneficial ownership is opaque, so a judgment against the employer may be unenforceable.
  • The manning agent is left. The RPSL agent placed the crew. If it did not verify the principal's insurance and financial security, the family's claim and the regulator's attention both turn to the agent.

The cargo-side consequences of shadow-fleet tonnage, where vessel quality clauses can void cargo cover, are a separate issue. On the crew side, the risk sits mainly with the Indian agency and the seafarer's family.

The Manning Agent's Own Cover: Employer's Liability, GPA and What the RPSL Guarantee Is Not

The RPSL financial security an agent maintains under the 2016 Rules is not liability insurance. It backs specific obligations, mainly around repatriation and employer default, and it does not defend or pay negligence claims brought by crew families. An agency that recruits for war-zone trades needs its own layers.

  • Employer's liability cover for claims that the agency, as a recruiter or deemed employer, failed in a duty it owed the seafarer, including placing crew on a vessel it should have known was underinsured or trading into designated areas without the uplifted terms.
  • Professional liability, for errors in documentation, verification and contract placement, which is often how such claims are pleaded.
  • Group personal accident (GPA) cover bought by the agency or the owner for crew, paying a fixed benefit on death or disablement regardless of fault. Check the war exclusion: many GPA wordings exclude war and warlike operations, which removes cover in exactly the waters where it matters. A war extension or a specialist crew accident policy written for listed areas is a separate purchase.

GPA does not replace the SEA compensation; it supplements it. Its value in a shadow-fleet case is that it is an Indian policy with an Indian insurer, paying the family directly, whether or not the vessel's P&I insurer ever responds.

What Indian Shipowners Using BMIP P&I Should Confirm

Indian owners now have a domestic option for the P&I entry itself. New India Assurance issued India's first Bharat Maritime Insurance Pool P&I policy to the Shipping Corporation of India on 30 July 2026, and IANS reported that BMIP had issued three P&I policies by 7 September 2026. Indian owners have otherwise relied largely on 13 international P&I clubs, according to the same report.

An owner moving crew liabilities to BMIP, or considering it, should confirm the following in writing:

  1. War perils treatment. Whether the BMIP entry excludes war liabilities to crew, and if so where the war P&I and excess war layers are placed and at what limits.
  2. CBA declaration. That the ITF, IBF or union agreements the crew sail under, including area uplifts, are declared and accepted as covered contractual liabilities.
  3. MLC certificates. Who issues the Regulation 2.5 and 4.2 certificates and whether flag states and port state control in the vessel's trading area accept them.
  4. Listed-area notice. The notice and additional premium mechanics for designated areas, and how quickly cover can be cancelled.
  5. Sanctions provisions. How the policy treats voyages or counterparties that later attract sanctions, since an Indian owner chartering into mixed trades can be caught by a counterparty's listing.

The answers matter as much for the manning agent as for the owner. An agent placing crew on a BMIP-entered ship is verifying a new policy form, and the same documentary discipline applies.

A Working Checklist After the Next Incident

Incidents off Oman and in the Black Sea in the space of about two weeks suggest Indian crew will keep working in waters where war perils are live. The sequence after a casualty is the same each time, and most of it depends on documents gathered before the voyage.

  • Fix the facts on the day. Vessel position against the designated area lists in force, the governing CBA, and the war cover status at the time of loss.
  • Notify every layer. P&I, war P&I, excess war, the MLC certificate issuer, the GPA insurer and the agency's own liability insurers. Late notice is a common reason crew claims stall.
  • Pay the family's immediate needs. Repatriation of remains, funeral costs and interim support should not wait for coverage arguments between insurers.
  • Track recoveries separately. Where a certificate issuer pays and seeks recovery from the owner, or an agency pays and pursues the principal, keep those disputes away from the family's claim.

The Cape Dao death will be resolved through the familiar chain if the war layer was in place. Aframax Rio shows what happens when there is no reliable chain to follow. For an Indian manning agent, the difference between those outcomes is largely decided at recruitment, when it chooses whom to place crew with and what it verifies before they board.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does P&I insurance pay compensation when a seafarer is killed by a missile or drone strike?
Not under the ordinary club cover. Standard P&I rules exclude liabilities caused by war perils, so a crew death from a strike on the vessel normally falls to war P&I under the hull war policy and then to the club's excess war P&I layer. Where the club has issued an MLC certificate for contractual death and disability compensation, it generally pays the certificated amount to the seafarer's family and then seeks recovery from the owner. Any war-zone uplift above that amount depends on the war layers being in place.
Is an Indian manning agent liable if the shipowner's insurance does not pay?
It can be. Under the Merchant Shipping (Recruitment and Placement of Seafarers) Rules, 2016, RPSL holders must place crew only under compliant employment agreements and verify that the principal can meet its obligations. If the owner's cover is absent or void, families often pursue the Indian agency as the reachable party, and DG Shipping can act against the licence. The RPSL financial security does not defend or pay negligence claims, so agencies need their own employer's liability and professional liability cover.
What happens to crew claims on a sanctioned or shadow-fleet tanker?
They are hard to collect. Such vessels often lack an International Group P&I entry, and where cover exists, sanctions clauses can allow the insurer to suspend it or treat it as void. The owner is commonly a single-ship company with opaque ownership. The 23 Indian crew of Aframax Rio, a tanker placed on Ukraine's sanctions list as part of Russia's shadow fleet on 12 February 2026, show the exposure: an Indian GPA policy and the agency's own liability cover may be the only reliable sources of payment.
Do group personal accident policies cover seafarers in war zones?
Many do not. GPA wordings commonly exclude war and warlike operations, which removes cover in the waters where crew face the highest risk. A war extension or a specialist crew accident policy written for listed areas has to be bought separately. Where it is in place, GPA pays a fixed benefit to the family directly from an Indian insurer, regardless of whether the vessel's P&I or war insurers respond.

Related Glossary Terms

Related Insurance Types

Related Industries

Related Articles

Sarvada Intelligence

Ready to see Sarvada in action?

Explore the platform workflow or start a product conversation with our underwriting automation team.

Explore the platform